Image courtesy of Tom Sanladerer's video on our Carbonyte filament
The availability of new, exciting 3D printing materials has increased dramatically in a few short years. Originally you were confined to just your regular PLA and ABS filaments on any machine costing less than $30,000 or so, now you’re able to print with nearly any (or certainly something close to any) material you want.
One of those exciting new developments is Carbon Fibre composite filaments. The properties of carbon fibre include incredible strength to weight ratio, rigid, good tensile strength and corrosion and fatigue resistance.
What is Carbon Filament?
It’s important not to get confused, or have unrealistic expectations here. Carbon fibre filament is not the same as the carbon fibre you might expect to find in high performance race cars or aircraft. The processes, materials used and the design are all completely different. Typical fibre based composites are large, long sheets of woven fibres sealed in a tough epoxy based resin. Not a re-meltable thermoplastic (like filaments are).
Frustratingly most CF (Carbon Fibre) filaments available at the moment are just PLA mixed with CF dust. Now PLA is typically very brittle, certainly most varieties of it are, and adding another brittle material in the form of a powder essentially creates one of the most brittle printing materials you could think of.
That’s the reason (and I may get slated for this) you’re not going to find Carbon Fiber PLA filament in this “best of” article. That’s because PLA does not compliment carbon.
For similar reasons we're also not going to cover Carbon Fiber ABS filament here either.
A better use of your time (and money, because CF filament isn’t cheap) would be to choose a base material with excellent durability to counter Carbon’s potentially brittle nature. That way, you’ll be left with prints that exude rigidity, hardness and durability. Which let’s face it, for high performance applications is the golden set of properties.
Materials like PETG, Nylon or other better performing resins, with small particles or strands of carbon fibre inside makes a closer to what you’d expect version of the material. The base resin used, amount of CF and size of the individual particles of carbon in the material affect a range of factors including printability, cost and finished part strength.
Make no mistake; The right blend of resin and CF can make a superior, hard, stiff and durable material that will rival and other filament available for consumer level FDM printing today. So for those projects where nothing else will do, carbon could be your go-to filament.
You can treat this article as a mini carbon fiber filament review. Let’s take a look at the 4 highest performance carbon composites currently available in the market today:
ColorFabb XT CF20 (Carbon Fibre PETG Filament) Price: Approx. £60/KG
Thought we’d kick things off with arguably the most well-known (and cheapest) CF material in this list. ColorFabb ‘XT’ is basically the same popular PETG (think PET in plastic bottles, but Glycol modified for strength) but with a 20% fibre reinforcement.
As with all CF materials, it’s important you use a hardened nozzle. A regular Brass nozzle will wear out in a few short hours of printing. XT CF20 is no different, so make sure you have some hardened nozzles to hand. It’s also worth bearing in mind most fibre or composite filaments are best printed with 0.5mm or larger nozzles. If the particles in the filament are not sufficiently nano-sized then blockages can occur easily on smaller nozzle sizes.
Similar to PLA, PETG filament is rather dense so naturally XT has a higher end density; coming in at 1.27 g/cm3. Not so much an issue when printing most things, but if weight is a concern you may be interested in lower density materials (like Nylon) that can be up to 20% lighter for the same volume.
ColorFabb is a known industry benchmark, promising tolerances of 0.05mm +/- of their advertised 1.75mm or 2.85mm sizes. Generally the tighter the tolerances, the cleaner your prints will look – so it’s worth watching out for. Tolerances that are too wide can even lead to blockages, so be wary of 0.10mm+/- variances in cheaper filaments.
Other benefits of XT CF20 in line with PETG filaments are low warp and good durability. It is worth taking into consideration the typical printing nuances of PETG for best results, which you can find more info on here.
MatterHackers 'NylonX' (Carbon Fibre Nylon Filament) Price: Approx. £110/KG
Although PETG based CF filaments are significantly better than ABS or PLA based composites, the ultimate harmony of materials is Nylon and CF combined. Nylon is we think, arguably the best material currently available to 3D print with for the majority of performance applications.
Nylon is one of those materials that just has it all. Extreme durability, great chemical and heat stability and a low friction coefficient to name a few properties. And with its great durability, it naturally makes for a perfect pairing with the otherwise fairly brittle CF.
Granted CF filaments have a rougher, matte finish – so the low friction advantage isn’t as good as non-composite Nylon, but it’s still a favourable factor over other base resin materials if this is a concern.
It’s worth noting though that Nylon filaments should always be dried before printing. Nylon is extremely hydroscopic and can absorb a lot of moisture in a short time frame. If you hear popping during printing, that’ll be too much moisture.
Again as with ColorFabb’s XT CF20 above, diameter tolerances are a reasonable 0.05mm+/- of the advertised size.
Onyx (Nylon Carbon Fiber Filament) Price: Approx. £200/KG
Another Nylon based CF Filament (can you see a trend here?) this one from Onyx. These are the guys behind the impressive Markforged 2 continuous fibre 3D printer. Using a continuous fibre, the prints you can get are closer in strength to more recognized carbon fibre materials. However, this continuous approach can only currently be done on the special Markforged printer.
For comparison, their carbon continuous filament is priced at eye-watering £2500/KG.
For everyone else, their original material ‘Onyx’ works in standard 3D printers and is simply a higher grade Nylon and Carbon Fibres. Similar to Nylon X (as above) but the quality is arguable more in keeping with what you’d expect from an ultra-high performance material.
The only down side with this filament is the price, as it the most expensive filament in this comparison.
As to which filament is for you, this is determined by what you’re actually needing it for and your budget. We’ve covered a cheap option, mid range and the high end of the market. We’ve not included it in this list, as we wanted it to be impartial – but we’ve also created a Nylon-CF filament called Carbonyte which you can view here. Our manufacturing controls and customer service are second to non.
Here's Thomas Sanladerer's video review of our Carbonyte you can watch here:
Please let us know your thoughts for this comparison guide, and feel free to leave comments or questions below. We’ll be only too happy to help. Liked this guide? Why not grab our Free Ultimate Guide to 3D Printing while your here.
It could save you some time and money.